The Court of Appeal has confirmed in R (on the application of TJ Trading Express Limited) v Secretary of State for the Home Department - dated 29 October 2026 - that Level 1 Users on an organisation’s sponsor licence must not assign a Certificate of Sponsorship (CoS) to themselves or a close relative.
Why was TJ Trading Express’ sponsor licence revoked?
TJ Trading Express Limited had its sponsor licence revoked in March 2024 because its director and Level 1 User assigned a CoS to his brother-in-law. He did not flag the close relationship with a sponsor note. There were also concerns about the genuineness of the role.
The company challenged the revocation in court on the basis that they should have been given the opportunity to explain the circumstances. This was initially successful, but the Home Office appealed the decision to the Court of Appeal. The Court overturned the first decision and upheld the revocation. They decided that a sponsor licence can be revoked immediately and without warning where there is a clear breach of the sponsor guidance.
Who counts as a “close relative” when assigning a CoS?
The Home Office guidance defines a close relative as any of the following:
- spouse, civil partner or unmarried partner
- parent
- child
- sibling
- nephew or niece
- aunt, uncle or cousin
Why does this matter for sponsors?
Assigning a CoS to yourself, your partner or close relative is a mandatory ground for revocation of the sponsor licence. If you want to assign a CoS to a close relative of someone working for the sponsor, it must be done by an unrelated Level 1 User, who must add a sponsor note to the CoS to explain the relationship.
The recent Court of Appeal decision reaffirms several key legal principles which apply to sponsor licence holders:
- Holding a sponsor licence is a privilege, not a right, and is conditional on compliance with the sponsor licence guidance.
- A high degree of trust is placed in sponsors and comes with significant responsibilities, including reading and remaining up-to-date with the Home Office’s guidance.
- The court’s role is supervisory, and it is primarily for the Home Office to decide the appropriate response where a sponsor breaches its compliance obligations.
- Where a breach falls within the mandatory grounds for revocation, the Home Office can revoke a sponsor licence immediately and without prior warning.
- The rules on assigning a CoS to a close relative are strict, and sponsors must ensure they follow the specific requirements in the sponsor guidance when doing so.
There is also a risk that, when further CoS are assigned, the Home Office may review previous activity on the Sponsor Management System (SMS) identify the issue and take action to revoke a sponsor’s licence.
The recent Court of Appeal decision highlights the potentially significant consequences of getting sponsor compliance wrong. For businesses that rely on sponsored workers, the consequences can be significant, both for the organisation and for the employees whose immigration status depends on that sponsorship.
What checks should sponsors make before assigning a CoS?
Sponsors should ensure their internal systems are robust enough to identify and flag any proposed CoS assignment involving the partner or close relative of someone working within the organisation before the CoS is assigned.
How can Thorntons help with sponsor licence compliance?
Our specialist sponsor licence team can provide tailored training on your sponsor licence duties and assist with any questions on immigration compliance.
We offer a sponsor licence maintenance service to help you manage your licence. This includes:
- Monthly checks of your sponsor licence;
- Refresher training on sponsor licence compliance and right to work;
- Updates on immigration law changes affecting your business and sponsored workers through access to our exclusive sponsor licence newsletter; and
- Ongoing advice on matters such as CoS, salary requirements and sponsor reporting duties.
For advice on assigning a CoS or managing your sponsor licence duties, contact Ross Drysdale, Immigration Solicitor or our specialist immigration team to discuss how we can support your business.